Wednesday, May 10, 2006

The Shoe Shine Boy has a Tip on a Fabulous 3BR/2BA


I don't know if it was Joseph Kennedy, John D. Rockefeller, some anonymous millionaire or just an urban legend, but the lesson lives today, and I am afraid that some warning signs are not being fully appreciated. The story goes something like this:

(Insert preferred Robber Baron here) was getting his shoes shined on a sidewalk near Wall Street, circa 1929. The shine boy was bursting at the seams with unsolicited stock tips. The savvy investor took this as a sign that the market was over-extended with a false confidence. Speculators had pitched valuations to unstable highs, setting the stage for a precipitous crash, and the investor cleared out before the stock tips 'hit the fan'...

Herbert Hoover also blamed the great stock market crash on speculators, suggesting that even "lowly bellboys" were attempting to mimic the legendary returns made by people like Jay Gould and Cornelius Vanderbilt.

This same environmental dynamic also held up under a microscope to the dotcom bust and associated NASDAQ tumble. Volume, valuation, and volatility were all riding high as a deluge of new investors gained easy access to the trading floor, and ignored some of the basics of investing. By and large, they were under-educated in the field of investing, and just like 1929, the fall-out rippled well beyond the speculative investor's financial world.

So what about housing in today's market? Clearly there is a bubble watch going on, as values have hit parabolic growth patterns, and sustainability concerns have set in. But housing data continues to be pretty strong, despite the media's repeated warnings. We have seen statistics suggesting that as much as 40% of the purchase volume in 2005 for houses was for investments or 2nd homes - indicative of speculative buying.

Anybody who has stayed up late once in a while has seen the infomercials catering to get-rich-quick in real estate programs. They usually involve a lot of interview snippets with average people sitting by a pool at some resort in Orlando, quoting their monthly income. They suggest that you should be able to easily buy houses with no investment of your own cash, and tease you to call for more info. And as the frequency of media comments about profits made by investors flipping property, and the huge profits being made in real estate in general, more and more people are sucked into this frenzy for real estate investments. I just worry that the investors are really not taking adequate care to educate themselves about real estate investing, and I sense an instability in this sector of the market.

As I said, the housing industry continues to turn in strong data. Employment growth and income growth are supporting a lot of the gains we have seen in housing costs. The Federal Reserve seems to have a good grip on inflation, and the economy seems healthy, and ready to ease off the throttle a bit. I don’t expect a crash in the values of people's homes. But to the extent that the market could be bolstered by a false sense of confidence - these investors who don't know what they're doing - I would advise exercising some caution when buying anything. History has a tendency to repeat. Be careful following the advice of infomercials.