Tuesday, August 28, 2007

The Shifting Mood Of The Market


The mood on Wall Street is all over the place right now. The "Credit Crunch" or "Liquidity Crisis" now seems to be a little bit harsh of a label for what is going on. Much of that panic and fear seems to have settled down. There are still plenty of concerns, and quite a bit to get worked out in the credit marketplace, particularly in the residential mortgage market. But I like the re-classification of the whole state of affairs by Barry Ritholtz as a Credibility Crisis. There is enough underlying strength in the economy, and even the housing market to keep this from being too critical of an event.

He suggests that liquidity is not the problem. The issue is that nobody with cash is willing to take the leap into credit products because the whistle has been blown on the obfuscation of risk via derivitization. In other words, nobody can see what they are buying, and now that risk feels risky, the money has moved to the sidelines until credibility can be restored. This market stagnation has locked up a lot of the fluid movement in the market, and caused several companies to freeze up and die.

The un-levering process - where companies scale down their borrowing - has an affect of pushing prices (stocks, bonds, and other dollar-denominated assets) down further, as they sell assets to cover borrowed funds, but think of it as 'cutting to the chase'; the values clearly needed to correct back down to a more stable level. If we can find stability before selling everything too far, we get closer to that 'soft landing' type of adjustment.

The sentiment regarding the Federal Funds rate, and the role of the US Federal Reserve is also shifting. Whereas the markets immediately assumed that a cut in the Discount Rate suggested a near-term cut in the Fed Funds Rate, there is now more chatter covering the reasons why the Fed still will not rush to make these cuts. Inflation needs to prove itself a non-threat, or we start this cycle all over again without allowing investors to feel the painful results of poor judgement.

The market is eagerly awaiting the reports on PCE (August 31) and Unemployment (Sept 7) for insight into the Fed's mindset. Some say the Fed will not cut rates before Unemployment ticks up at least 0.2% (to 4.8). And the PCE reading needs to show a year-over-year of below 2.0% (currently at about 1.9, but close enough to the 2.0 to remain a concern).

Stay tuned... as I often say, there are a lot of moving targets involved, and the mood changes as the data rolls in...

Monday, August 27, 2007

How A Recession In Housing Affects The Rest Of The Economy


Watch CNBC for 5 minutes and 30 seconds and you can get a good sense of the attention being paid to the day-to-day developments in the housing and mortgage markets. At this point it is no secret (or real surprise) that the housing industry is in a recession. We have increasing inventory, slowing sales, and decreasing prices. The construction unemployment rates are rising. The mortgage industry is facing a fairly turbulent adjustment with several companies collapsing on short-notice, and leaving several consumers left waiting for the money to buy their homes.

But most agree that these adjustments are good for the industry's long-term benefit. This is typical of the market cycle. Its just that the other side of the cycle carried the industry so far for so long, that this side feels more intense.

Paul Kasriel of Northern Trust highlights some of the ways in which the housing industry's growing pains can spill over into the greater economy:

"The tentacles of the housing recession are reaching beyond consumer spending. Freight haulers, both truck and rail, are reporting weaker volume growth because of the decline in residential construction activity. With fewer housing developments popping up in suburbia, newspaper advertising revenues are being adversely affected. And the producers of construction equipment, such as Caterpillar, are experiencing softer domestic sales."
It will be interesting to watch this develop. And of particular interest will be to monitor the role of the Federal Reserve, who is attempting to tread a fine line between averting a significant economic recession and giving the market participants false confidence through bail-out gestures.

Friday, August 17, 2007

Fed Cuts Discount Rate


Jim Cramer got what he was looking for. This morning, the Fed lowered their Discount Rate by .500%, taking it from 6.250% down to 5.750%. The discount Rate is the rate at which the Fed lends money directly to commercial banks, credit unions and savings and loans, including large lenders like Countrywide and Bank of America. It is different than the Fed Funds Rate, which is the rate at which banks lend money to other banks. The Discount rate is usually held 1.000% above the Fed Funds Rate, which makes the Fed a last resort for lending institutions to borrow from. They would generally rather borrow from other banks at a lower rate, but with the current liquidity crisis making that difficult, this move will help provide some liquidity at more desirable rates in the short term.

This move has a direct benefit to banks and lenders more so than to consumers. The Fed is taking baby steps to help put some lubrication into the markets while being careful not to send the message that they will serve as a 'lender of last resort' to bail out institutions and individuals who face suffering loss as a result of poor decision making. This move softens things a little, but is not a bail-out move. They will let the markets second-guess recent behavior and correct themselves, but need to help guide so as to avoid a complete systemic breakdown. Its a fine line, and this is a baby step. The next few weeks will certainly be interesting, to see how much adjustment can be made, and how much stability can be built back

Wednesday, August 15, 2007

What Do Fed Rate Actions Do To Mortgage Rates?


Thanks to this chart from HSH, you can see that the answer is "not much", at least not for mortgages based on long-term rates. The Fed changes the short-term or "overnight" rates to affect the costs of borrowing so that institutions and individuals will be more or less inclined to borrow to fund growth or expenditures. Higher rates means less spending, and the Fed has recently raised rates 17 times to try and slow down our hot economy to a more sustainable pace.

Mortgage rates are determined by the trade value of mortgage backed securities (RMBS), which are bond-type securities whose cashflow is generated by mortgage debt. The liquid value of these bonds reflect longer-term expectations of economic performance, and do not always move with the Fed Funds rate.

Back when the Fed was still raising rates (the incline on the tan line), there was a lot of expectation that this would pressure up the other longer-term rates. But it didn't, and we wound up with a flat and inverted yield curve. Then we heard an ongoing debate between economists who felt the inverted yield curve indicated the foretelling of a recession, and those who felt that this was a poor predictive tool. Now there are more folks on the recession bandwagon...

A higher Fed Funds rate does affect homeowners with significant home equity lines of credit however. HELOCs are based on the Prime rate, which moves in lock-step with the Fed Funds rate. If you have a sizable HELOC, you've probably already noticed your financing get a little top-heavy over the last few years. You will see some relief if the Fed starts to cut rates soon.

Sunday, August 12, 2007

Contagion Visualized


Take a look at the interactive map of the credit crunch from Financial Times...

Friday, August 10, 2007

Fed Steps In To Calm Nerves?

Markets sure can be moody. Yesterday and today, the US Federal Reserve 'injected liquidity' into the markets to the tune of $38 billion in an effort to try and calm things down. Expectations of Federal Funds rate cuts have quickly changed, with 33% chance of a cut before the next Fed meeting in September. Last time the Fed changed rates off the scheduled meetings was in the wake of 9-11.

So the stock markets around the globe have been in a roil over all of this credit crunching. Shouldn't they be happy to see the Fed taking action? Or does the fact that they are reacting on the fly suggest to the markets that the Fed is officially acknowledging a problem? Security vs. Uncertainty. Markets hate uncertainty, and there will be a negative tone out there until it has evaporated.

While the Fed was raising rates in this last cycle - 17 consecutive 0.250% hikes over a two year period - mortgage rates often went down at each interval. This is often counter-intuitive, but if you can read between the lines it makes sense. Even though Fed rate hikes meant that the environment for interest rates was rising, the fact that the Fed was doing battle with inflation by raising over-night rates made bond investors happy, so they bought more bonds and brought long term rates lower. Security vs. Uncertainty again.

Meanwhile, check out Mr. Mad Money flipping his lid while talking about the current market conditions. Just another measurement of our current state of markets in 'panic mode'. If you are (or are not) familiar with Jim Cramer, here's a great chance to get a glimpse of the guy.

Thursday, August 09, 2007

So Much For The Soft Landing Theory?


Holy smokes! The market is changing quickly, as the 'other side' of the cycle has arrived with a thud. Rates and products in the mortgage market are changing rapidly, and many homeowners are going to get caught up in the crossfire. Last week at American Home Mortgage, 800 Million dollars of would-be loan funds piled up in just 3 days as the company announced that it would not fund deals that had already signed. Forget those in underwriting, application, etc. 800 Million dollars - that's a lot of homes! Think of the domino effect of broken purchase contracts, failed credit payments, etc. This kind of spiral is what causes the market to buckle, and why a quick change in liquidity is referred to as a "crunch" or "crisis". Read more about it here, or here, or here.

As for today specifically, Mortgage Bonds are trading higher on unexpected news from Europe connected to US sub-prime mortgage investing problems, as well as Stocks trading lower off the same news. French Bank BNP Paribas, second largest bank in Europe, announced it has temporarily halted withdrawals in three of its mutual funds that have exposure to US subprime credit. As you can imagine, investors like you and I, who are told that their own funds are not available for withdrawal, would be quite worried. In the day's only economic news, Initial Jobless Claims edged higher by 7,000 claims to 316,000, the highest weekly total since June 30 - a positive factor for the Bond market.

I often talk about the book "Manias, Panics and Crashes". About a year ago I started reading this book again, and everyone looked at me like I was a doomsayer. But there is so much historical information in this book that can be applied to the current situation. It gives a detailed look at the anatomy of an asset cycle, and when and where systemic breakdown can occur. Rather than stick your head in the sand, take a look at it and consult with a professional about your finances, so that you can be sure you are prepared to weather this storm in housing and the mortgage market. Are you liquid enough to get through this?? It promises to get at least a little uglier before the dust settles. But this correction will be healthy for the long run.