Saturday, September 09, 2006

In Defense of The Option ARM


Business Week recently published a scathing article about Adjustable-Rate Pay-Option Mortgages (aka The Option ARM) that has sent a pretty good ripple through the lending community. Well, big surprise, this one-sided eye-grabbing piece is typical of the flesh-eating virus style of media-induced panic.

Before I defend this loan product outright, I want to be clear on something: there is no doubt in my mind that this is an often-abused and often-misunderstood product. But I do feel the need to point out a few problems with the article, and and present another side to these loans. Read the article here.

The key benefit for Option ARMs is the payment flexibility, where a borrower is allowed to make minimal monthly payments on their home loan. It is a strictly cash-flow driven financial tool, and generally is not the cheapest type of loan available. As is with any other time value of money concept, you are paying a premium for this flexibility. This may be in the form of higher interest cost, higher risk of increasing interest, or in the current rate environment, both.

Business Week makes a fair claim that many mortgage brokers are pushing this product for inappropriate borrower scenarios, and this is a real problem that I agree with. The simplified sequence looks a little like this:

Home owners are attracted by the low minimum payments - commonly featured in mortgage broker's radio and print advertisements - and do not ultimately understand how the loan works before they sign up. They make minimum payments for a while, and then get caught by surprise when they realize that (A) their loan is growing in size and (B) their payments minimums are adjusting to keep pace with this increasing balance. Add to the mix a realization of a slowing appreciation rate for US real estate, and the stage is set a full-blown panic. All the media needs to do to sell a few magazines is run headlines like "Nightmare Mortgages".

Throughout this article, BW gives examples of some people who are feeling the pinch of rising rates and payments on their Option-ARM. She presents that they have been screwed by their mortgage broker, and that the mortgage broker has been led along like a puppy by banks to sell these products by offering high margin revenues for the product. Its the man stickin' it to the people yet again, and the result is a shaky American financial infastructure, ready to buckle beneath its own weight when Mr. & Mrs. Average Homeowner come up short on their upwardly adjusting mortgage payments.

Let's not forget how the media makes a living. Do I have to make the case that they have a history of blowing things out of proportion? Is it obvious already that they sell more magazines, more commercial time, more web impressions when they have really dramatic news to talk about? A recent James Bond movie made fun of a corrupt media mogul who was creating global conflict to sell newspapers. Its a parody, but it comes from the every day media machine.

And they are blowing things out of proportion here...

First, no responsibility is put on the borrower, the consumer, the buyer to educate themselves. The American consumer is presented as a feather in the wind, succeptable to any mortgage broker's lousy self-serving advice. I don't buy it. The consumer controls the mortgage process more today than ever, educated (albeit in a commonly misleading way) to a dangerous degree. They think they know it all, but they dont know enough. They surf the web for info, and think they can walk into the transaction telling the mortgage broker what is best for them in the mortgage universe, and how much it should cost. What choice does a mortgage broker have but to tell them what they want to hear, that the lowest payment out there is based on a 1% Option ARM start rate?

Well, that is your common mortgage broker for you. So who can blame the consumer for making every attempt to arm themselves with the latest info, and come in to the transaction with their defenses in place? The consumer fears the mortgage broker, and the mortgage broker fears the consumer. This is a recipe for a bad deal. From my perspective, this is the 'Nightmare Mortgage'. All this drama about Option ARMs is just a symptom of that problem.

In most of the case studies, there is no mention of the situation prior to the Option ARM. Most of these people are in over their heads already. Harold can't afford any mortgage product on the income quoted. The Shaw's dont have enough income to qualify for their mortgage, etc. Did the Option ARM really get them in trouble, or are were they already headed there? Maybe they mismanaged their finances, or just had some tough turns in life. It happens.

But lets not let these folks get away with blaming everything on the bank or the broker. While I do agree with some abuse from inside the business, is the consumer not required to take responsibility of their own situation? Not reading the terms? Not taking the care to find a reputable broker? I mean, I can go into WalMart and buy a shotgun, but if I shoot somebody with it, I am not allowed to blame it to the blue-vested clerk who rang the register...

These loans are promoted with 1%-2% pay rates as the hook. Does it not seem too good to be true? It is! Theres more to this story - a lot more! I hear radio ads for these, and I get the flyers in the mail. Most of the advertisements seem criminal to me. And I do think that a large segment of this industry is participating in a misleading game, and delivering a back-handed slap to people in a time-sensitive, major financial transaction - often leaving them with little choice or time to react once they realize the bigger picture.

To date I have talked more people out of the Option-ARM than I have put into the Option-ARM. But we still put them together for the right situations.

In todays marketplace for real estate finance, there are countless options. There are so many products that can be tweaked to fit a loan scenario, where you can emphasize one goal over another - financial, personal, etc (related to taxes, investments, inherritance, divorce, retirement, education, timing... the list can go on and on...). The Option ARM represents one of the most sophisticated tools available, but you need to know when and why it is right for you. A Certified Mortgage Planner isn't likely to lead you astray; make sure you are working with somebody who can educate you, and plan with you to weave the mortgage product with your greater financial goals.

Work with an expert. Get a referral from somebody you trust. And then let them work with you to provide a mortgage plan. Only you know your financial habits and objectives. And I guarantee you that a good mortgage planner knows a lot more about their business landscape than you do. If you can't put trust in them to help you navigate real estate finance decisions, then its not the right person to work with.