More Signs Of A Topping Market - From Luxury Alternative Investments, And Some Market Chatter

It has been well publicized that asset markets have cycled higher in value in recent quarters, largely attributable to strong economic growth worldwide, and cheap and easy access to cash, credit and liquidity. Low rates from the US Federal reserve, as well as other countries like Japan (where the Fed Funds equivalent was at 0.000% for 8 years... 0%!! .... 8 years!!!) encouraged investors and consumers to borrow and invest and save, and economies boomed and everything got more expensive. We have seen it in the stock markets, bond markets, housing, commodities, precious metals, corporate buy-outs, you name it.

But there is another set of asset markets that tend to receive a little less publicity, and whose cycles often signal the peaking of exuberant money. In July 06, John Mauldin writes:

"Art, Wine & Horses

One of the recurrent themes of our research has been that it has "never been so expensive to be rich" and that this situation will only likely deteriorate. But even with that in mind, we have to admit that we have been floored by the recent activity at the high end of the market. Take wine, art & horses as examples. As most of our readers will know, modern art, fine wines, & horses, are assets that tend to peak just before the start of a pronounced downturn of the economic cycle. And interestingly, over the past couple of months, these assets have really been shooting up, breaking several records on the way:

* The US$16 million horse. A few months ago, a two-year-old colt who has yet to run a race drew a world record sale price of US$16 million at an auction in Florida, after a furious bidding war between Englishman Michael Tabor and Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al Maktoum of Dubai (could he be thinking that horses will run better than Dubai stocks?). The sale broke the previous record of US$13.1 million paid in the mid-1980s for Seattle Dancer. Considering that very few horses ever reach winnings of US$1 million and that the all-time leading earner, Cigar, took home close to US$ 10 million, this is a truly mind-boggling price to pay for a horse that has yet to race a single race (incidentally, Seattle Dancer, the previous record holder, went on to win a paltry US$150,000, racing only five times in his short career).

* The unbottled 2005 Bordeaux. In the world of wine investments, Bordeaux is king, with up to US$3.7 billion worth of wines changing hands every year. Over the past twelve months, much to Charles' chagrin (who likes to say that he is now too old to drink cheap wines), the price of top vintages have surged more than +45%. Much of this latest rally can be attributed to the - yet to be bottled - 2005 vintage. The 2005 vintage from some of the top chateaux are reportedly selling for around US$9,000 per case; as a comparison, in 2003, the same wines went for about US$3,800 per case... While investing in wine can be a very risky business, there is one undeniable advantage: if all else fails, it is a liquid asset...

* The US$135 million portrait. A few weeks ago, Robert Lauder bought a portrait by Gustav Klimt for a staggering US$135 million, the highest sum ever paid for a painting, eclipsing a Picasso sold for US$104 million in 2004. While we (by no means) would pass for art connoisseurs, prices do seem to have reached stratospheric heights. In his latest Gloom Boom Doom report, our good friend Marc Faber, describes his visit to the June Basel Art Fair, where one pure black canvas had a price tag of US$1.5 million... "

Sotheby's International, pedaler of all such things luxury is one good barometer of these markets. Look at a Sotheby's share price 2 year chart. Look like the peak has been reached? The company got kicked by shareholders today after a staggeringly poor auction result. Implication? Money is dried up. Sellers think the peak has been reached.

Paul McCulley of Pimco recently described liquidity as follows:

"... liquidity is not a pool of money but rather a state of mind. ... liquidity is about borrowers and lenders collective appetite for risk, a function of: The willingness of investors to underwrite risk and uncertainty with borrowed money and the willingness of savers to lend money to investors who want to underwrite risk and uncertainty with borrowed money..."

So with all that has been going on along with this subprime virus, and its mutating its way through our credit markets right now, its no wonder everyone is getting a tight grip on their wallets. As new stories about financial loss break daily, the confrontation with reality becomes more real. The reason for the lag between the rising rates (the Fed started raising rates in 2004) and the realization of a liquidity crisis is because, as McCulley puts it, liquidity has more to do with psychology than it does with capital.

Likewise, it will take some time for the recent Fed cuts (and the coming ones as well) to work their way through the markets and translate to brighter attitudes and expectations. Banks - who have tightened up guidelines after-the-fact, will not un-pucker until after a bottom in housing is evident. Great quote from Pimco's Bill Gross, who describes the current situation as "closing the barn door after the subprime mortgage horse has escaped from the barn."

Pretty much. Going to be some bumps in the road, but I would not underestimate the mortgage industry to come up with some creative ways to work through some of the problems, and rescue the good deals from distress; not everybody facing pain in the housing market right now deserves to be there. We shall see...