Trabajadores Escondidos - Why Construction Industry Contraction and Unemployment Data Do Not Correlate

With the slow-down in the housing market comes a slow-down in the housing industry. This is why economists fear that a drastic correction in housing prices will have the kind of ripple effect that could send the US Economy into a recession. If the appetite for housing slows, fewer construction workers (and Realtors, mortgage brokers, appraisers, title/escrow... etc) can find employment. We are seeing pretty big drops in some of the housing construction data now - fewer homes being built, fewer permits applied for - and expectations have been that we would see a rise in unemployment related to this. The housing industry is assuredly large enough to influence that number.

But the unemployment rate has remained stubbornly low, keeping pressure on the Federal Reserve to watch out for 'wage-based' inflation, aka too many workers making too much money. So where are all the laid-off construction people now, if not unemployed?

A few months ago I read a fascinating piece forwarded by a favorite economist and author, John Mauldin, which explored not only the concept that much of the construction labor is undocumented workers, and therefore not showing up in official unemployment records, but also the impact this might have on the global economy. Much of the money earned by undocumented workers is sent back across borders to Latin American family back home. The central banks of these countries literally count on this cash in their economy, and it affects their own policy decisions and economic steering. The essay's question: do these countries know as much about this housing slow-down as we do? If not, there is risk of a ripple-effect well beyond our borders. And in today's global economy, those ripples bounce back and forth across borders. Interesting stuff.

Last month at the Pacific Coast Builders Conference in San Francisco, there was a panel titled Immigration, Labor and the Future of the American Workforce which focused on the importance of immigrant laborers to the home-building industry. And Jerry Nickelsburg with the Anderson Forecast group at UCLA recently published a report about a study on these "Hidden Workers".

With the immigration debate and legislation proposals, keep an eye on this topic in the coming months...

John C. Glynn, CMPS
Real Estate Finance & Mortgage Planning
San Francisco